Comfrey Crowns vs Root Cuttings: Which Should You Choose?

What Are Comfrey Crowns?

Comfrey crowns are sections cut from the top portion of mature comfrey plants. They include the crown (where the stems meet the roots), growing buds, and a portion of the root system. Think of them as "mini plants" that already have everything needed to quickly establish.

Advantages of Comfrey Crowns

• Faster Establishment: Crowns typically show new growth within 2-4 weeks of planting.
• Higher Success Rate: With proper planting, nearly all crowns will successfully establish.
• Earlier Harvests: You can often harvest leaves in the same growing season you plant.
• Less Maintenance: Crowns require less attention during establishment than root cuttings.
• Immediate Identification: You can verify you're getting the correct variety immediately.

Disadvantages of Comfrey Crowns

• Higher Cost: Crowns typically cost 3-4 times more than root cuttings.
• Limited Availability: Fewer suppliers offer crowns, especially during peak seasons.
• Bulkier Shipping: Crowns are larger and more expensive to ship.
• Shorter Viability: Must be planted relatively quickly after harvesting.

What Are Comfrey Root Cuttings?

Comfrey root cuttings are sections cut from the roots of mature comfrey plants. They are typically 2-6 inches long and about the thickness of a pencil. When planted, these root fragments will develop both new roots and shoots to form a complete plant.

Advantages of Root Cuttings

• Lower Cost: Root cuttings are significantly less expensive than crowns.
• Greater Quantity: You can get many more plants for the same price.
• Easier Shipping: Roots are smaller and lighter, reducing shipping costs.
• Longer Viability: Root cuttings can remain viable for weeks if stored properly.
• Ideal for Large Areas: Cost-effective way to establish comfrey in larger spaces.

Disadvantages of Root Cuttings

• Slower Establishment: Can take 2-3 months to develop into visible plants.
• Lower Success Rate: Some cuttings may fail to sprout.
• Delayed Harvests: Usually no significant harvest until the second growing season.
• More Maintenance: Require more careful attention during establishment.
• Weed Competition: Slow growth means more potential for weed competition.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Comfrey Crowns If:

• You want quick results and harvests in the first season
• You're only planting a few comfrey plants
• You're new to gardening and want the highest chance of success
• You're willing to pay more for convenience and reliability
• You need to verify you're getting the correct variety immediately

Choose Root Cuttings If:

• You're on a budget and cost is a primary concern
• You're planting a large area with many comfrey plants
• You're patient and don't need immediate results
• You have experience with plant propagation
• You're buying from a trusted source that guarantees variety

Planting Tips for Success

For Comfrey Crowns:

1. Plant as soon as possible after receiving.
2. Ensure the crown is positioned with buds facing upward.
3. Plant so the top of the crown is 1-2 inches below soil surface.
4. Water thoroughly after planting and keep soil consistently moist until established.
5. Expect new growth within 2-4 weeks, depending on the season and temperature.

For Root Cuttings:

1. Plant horizontally about 2-3 inches deep.
2. Space multiple cuttings about 2-3 inches apart if planting in clusters.
3. Mark planting locations clearly, as emergence can take time.
4. Keep soil consistently moist but not waterlogged.
5. Be patient - shoots may take 4-8 weeks to emerge, depending on conditions.
6. Protect the area from weeds until plants are well-established.